Something I should have posted a link to earlier - the best archive of the original Wondercafe is here:
http://wondercafe.altervista.org/www.wondercafe.ca/index.html
This archive is seen as “unauthorized” by the United Church of Canada, who abandoned the website and its users in 2014.
You can use Google to search the archive by pasting this into your browser:
SEARCH site:wondercafe.altervista.org/www.wondercafe.ca/
Replace “SEARCH” with the text you are looking for.
The old site is also available (if painfully slowly) at Wayback Machine here:
https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/wondercafe.ca
No word on what the United Church thinks of Wayback Machine or if they have sent any emails asking them to take their archive down.